Culture Powers Business™

Search
Close this search box.

Bridging the Skills Gap: Addressing 10 Critical Challenges of a Stagnant Workforce in Manufacturing

workforce
In the high-stakes world of large-scale manufacturing, where efficiency, innovation, and competitiveness are non-negotiable, a well-equipped workforce is more than just an asset—it’s a critical component of success.

However, when companies neglect the continuous development of their employees, the consequences can be severe and far-reaching.

This article, and follow-on series, explore the significant costs and challenges associated with a stagnant workforce and underscores the vital importance of upskilling or reskilling to meet the ever-evolving labor demands of the manufacturing industry, especially in the face of persistent skilled labor shortages.

The Ongoing Struggle to Fill Manufacturing Jobs

The U.S. manufacturing sector is continuing to grapple with a significant labor shortage, a challenge that carries profound implications for the industry’s future. According to a study by SME (Society of Manufacturing Engineers), as of January 2024, manufacturing job openings exceeded available workers in 48 states, with some states facing a disparity of more than 20,000 unfilled positions. This shortage is further compounded by the fact that many of these jobs require specialized skills that are not readily available in the current labor market.

The Manufacturing Institute also projects that by 2030, this skills gap could leave as many as 2.1 million manufacturing jobs unfilled, potentially costing the U.S. economy a staggering $1 trillion annually in lost revenue​.

This shortage is driven by several factors, including the retirement of baby boomers, the rapid pace of technological change, and the declining number of younger workers entering the manufacturing sector.

Given this dire situation, the need for upskilling and reskilling within the existing workforce has never been more urgent. These strategies are not just essential to fill current job vacancies, but also to ensure that the manufacturing sector can adapt to future technological advancements and remain competitive on a global scale.

Understanding Upskilling and Reskilling

Upskilling involves enhancing an employee’s current skills to improve performance in their existing role while reskilling focuses on training employees to take on entirely new roles within the organization. Both strategies have become essential as automation and technological advancements reshape the manufacturing landscape.

Beyond the Obvious: The High Cost of a Stagnant Workforce

While the negative impacts of a stagnant workforce on productivity, efficiency, and talent acquisition are widely recognized, several less obvious but equally damaging challenges warrant closer attention:

1The Amplified Impact of Automation:

Automation is transforming the manufacturing landscape at an unprecedented pace. According to a recent study, by 2030, up to 800 million jobs could be displaced by automation, necessitating significant upskilling efforts to mitigate the impact on the workforce. Without upskilling, businesses risk being left behind as competitors fully embrace automation and its benefits, leading to diminished market share and profitability.

2The Growing Importance of Non-Technical Skills:

In today’s dynamic work environment, technical skills alone are insufficient. Critical thinking, problem-solving, decision making, communication, and collaboration skills are increasingly crucial for success. A workforce lacking these skills will struggle to adapt to change, work effectively in teams, and contribute to a positive company culture. A LinkedIn survey found that 92% of talent professionals believe soft skills are just as essential as hard skills, and 89% believe bad hires often lack the necessary soft skills.

3The Widening Digital Divide:

The manufacturing industry increasingly relies on digital technologies such as data analytics, machine learning, and advanced robotics. An MIT study found that companies leading in digital transformation achieve 26% higher profitability than their peers. A workforce that lacks the digital literacy and skills necessary to leverage these technologies will find itself at a significant competitive disadvantage.

4The Erosion of Innovation and Problem-Solving Capabilities:

A stagnant workforce is less likely to challenge the status quo, think creatively, or develop innovative solutions. This incumbrance can stifle innovation, hinder continuous improvement efforts, and ultimately limit a company’s ability to compete in the marketplace. According to McKinsey, companies prioritizing innovation are twice as likely to report strong revenue growth.

5The Impact on Employee Mental Health and Well-being:

Employees who feel undervalued, stuck in a dead-end job, and lacking growth opportunities are at risk of experiencing poor mental health. This workplace reality for many can lead to increased absenteeism, presenteeism, and turnover, exacerbating the challenges faced by the organization. According to the World Health Organization, depression and anxiety have a significant economic impact, with an estimated cost of $1 trillion per year in lost productivity.

6Difficulty Adapting to New Safety Protocols and Regulations:

As safety regulations evolve and new technologies emerge, a workforce that isn’t upskilled or reskilled may struggle to adapt, leading to increased risks of accidents, injuries, and compliance issues. Ensuring your workforce is continuously trained on the latest safety protocols is crucial to maintaining a safe working environment and avoiding costly legal repercussions.

7Loss of Institutional Knowledge:

Experienced employees possess invaluable knowledge and insights gained over years of service. Without upskilling, reskilling, and knowledge transfer initiatives, the potential loss of this critical information when these employees retire or leave the company could be devastating. A study by the Manufacturing Institute found that 83% of executives consider the loss of institutional knowledge due to retirement a significant challenge.

8Ineffective Leadership and Management :

In a rapidly changing environment, the importance of effective leadership and management cannot be overstated. When managers and supervisors lack the skills to lead and develop their teams, it creates a ripple effect of inefficiency, disengagement, and poor performance throughout the organization. According to Gallup, leadership training can improve team productivity by up to 25%.

9Missed Opportunities for Cost Savings and Process Improvement:

An upskilled workforce is more likely to identify areas for improvement, streamline processes, and reduce waste, leading to significant cost savings and increased efficiency. A report by PwC found that companies with comprehensive upskilling programs see a 12% reduction in operational costs.

10Inability to Scale and Grow:

In today’s competitive landscape, manufacturers must be agile and adaptable to seize new opportunities and expand their operations. A workforce that lacks the necessary skills and knowledge can hinder a company’s ability to scale and grow effectively. Data from the National Skills Coalition suggests that businesses investing in workforce development are far more likely to expand their market presence successfully.

Filling the Skills Gaps:
A Strategic Investment for the Future

Given these pressing challenges, it’s evident that upskilling your workforce is not just a beneficial initiative but a strategic imperative for large-scale manufacturers. By prioritizing employee development, companies can:

Stay tuned for our complete Bridging the Skills Gap Mastery Series, where we’ll explore deeper issues brought to light by failing to develop your workforce, and share actionable strategies to mitigate their impact.

Conclusions for Operations Leaders

Continuous improvement isn’t just about systems and processes, it’s also about your people! Upskilling and reskilling your workforce is a critical investment in your company’s future. By taking a proactive approach to employee development, you can give your workforce the tools to meet the challenges of tomorrow and secure your organization’s long-term success.

At POWERS, we specialize in helping manufacturers develop and implement effective workforce development programs that deliver measurable results, particularly for frontline leaders.

Contact us today to learn how we can empower your workforce and achieve manufacturing excellence.

Schedule a free consultation with a POWERS expert to assess your downtime risks and discover how our proven methodologies and cutting-edge technology can help minimize disruptions, optimize production, and achieve sustainable success.

Get the latest Culture Performance Management insights delivered to your inbox

About the Author

Dr. Donte Vaughn, DM, MSM, Culture Performance Management Advisor
Dr. Donte Vaughn, DM, MSM

Chief Culture Officer

Dr. Donte Vaughn is CEO of CultureWorx and Culture Performance Management Advisor to POWERS.

Randall Powers, Founder, Managing Partner
Randall Powers

Managing Partner

Randall Powers concentrates on Operational and Financial Due Diligence, Strategic Development,, and Business Development.